2012 Talking Points: Rachel, Thomas, George, and Me

Most weekdays I watch the videos from the previous night’s Rachel Maddow Show, and, as you can well imagine, very often I join in the discussion myself. Yesterday Thomas Frank, author of Pity the Billionaire, was one of Rachel’s guests.

Thomas: You and I can sit here and say we’ve been engaged in conservative politics in this country for 30, maybe 40 years … privatizing, deregulating, deunionizing, outsourcing, all of this sort of thing, but their answer to that is, “Uh-uh. We just haven’t gone far enough. And we’ll never be prosperous again until the day we deregulate all the way and we privatize everything. Until then you can’t say that laissez-faire or the free market has been discredited, because we haven’t been allowed to do every last little thing that we want.” …

Rachel: Your thesis absolutely has helped me understand what happened in 2010 and how the simplistic—incredible but simplistic—and vehement argument that sounds simple and effective repeated loudly can work. …

Me: So this explains why the “trickle-down economics,” “government-is-the-problem,” “deregulate-and-privatize-everything” ideas still have traction? Because they’ve been repeated loudly and vehemently and often enough? No wonder it seems like so much of public discourse has become a fact-free zone.

Perhaps this touches on one of progressives’ greatest difficulties. We like reasoned discussions; we like exchanging ideas of merit; we like refuting right-wing pundits’ assertions. But when we do that, we often respond using the right’s own language and ideas; we let them frame the discussion and we don’t get to our own frames.

Let’s invite George Lakoff, author of Thinking Points: Communicating Our American Values and Vision, to join us.

George: Progressives have a basic morality, which is largely unspoken. It has to be spoken, over and over, in every corner of our country. Progressives need to be both thinking and talking about their view of a moral democracy, about how a robust Public is necessary for private success, about all that the Public gives us, about the benefits of health, about a Market for All not a Greed Market, about regulation as protection, about revenue and investment, about corporations that keep wages low when profits are high, about how most of the rich earn a lot of their money without making anything or serving anyone, about how corporations govern your life for their profit not yours, about real food, about corporate and military waste, about the moral and social role of unions, about how global warming causes the increasingly monstrous effects of weather disasters, about how to save and preserve nature.

Progressives have magnificent stories of their own to tell. They need to be telling them nonstop.

Me: So in essence, this is what the right has been doing so effectively. They have hammered on their talking points until everyone is parroting them, not just the party faithful. Of course, it doesn’t hurt that the right has its own 24/7 propaganda machine that happily reiterates right-wing frames over and over again. Still, you have to admit, they’ve been good at this stuff and progressives have not.

In the coming election year, beloveds, let’s quit reacting to the right’s provocations and focus like a laser on what we believe in: representative democracy, clean and transparent government, opportunity for all, the common good, the Bill of Rights, the well-being of the 99%, social as well as individual responsibility, inclusiveness and diversity, and compassion and empathy.


4 thoughts on “2012 Talking Points: Rachel, Thomas, George, and Me

  1. We “progressives” are fighting a rear guard action against a well entrenched and incredibly well funded propaganda campaign. Whence the word Propaganda? From Nazi Germany—Not the Soviet Union as Gingrich et ‘al claim. Yes, true fascists are running this disinformation campaign. It is past time to fight back with the real facts–and there are plenty. The problem is 2 fold, we need a forum where Republicans tune in and “we” need the facts and flip charts to illustrate them. You say; “aren’t flip charts simplistic?” Of course they are—that’s why they work! Americans don’t like to read and their attention span matches that of a gray squirrel. Hence, the facts mam—just the facts. Big bold lettering and numbers even a first grade student can understand. Leave the explanation for Rachael—she’s perhaps the best spokesperson “we” have.

    Da Rev

    • The 24/7 propaganda machine that is Fox “News” is formidable. What they hammer home over and over again are values that viewers identify with. That’s at least part of why they get away with saying the outrageous things they do. The right thinks it has a corner on “values voters,” and progressives have just let them think that. But what many don’t realize is that ALL of us voters are values voters. Progressives need to get better at expressing their values, and express them often. I’m reading Lakoff’s “Thinking Points: Communicating Our American Values and Vision,” and I highly recommend it. I think Lakoff’s onto something very important when he talks about effectively communicating our values.

  2. Labor can be the strongest weapon we have to fight for a decent society if it transforms itself into a Social Movement. The end game for labor can no longer be signing a contract with the employer. We have to be prepared to fight a long term class war against the agents of the authoritarian-corporate agenda.

    • Agreed. The transformation is essential. And part of that transformation must be in our vision and our language. More than anything else, our vision of ourselves must change. We are not postal workers and health care workers. We are the workers. We are the heart and soul of this country. We can no longer allow ourselves to be pitted against each other. We are the 99%!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s