Nondebatable!

The Wisconsin State Senate today passed a bill requiring that Wisconsin women seeking an abortion undergo a medically unnecessary ultrasound procedure, after which the physician must give an account of the number of “unborn children” present, the characteristics, dimensions, and location in the womb. Because, of course, women are too ignorant to know “what they’re carrying in their womb and what they’re doing” unless it’s rammed down their throats. Senator Mary Lazich (R) has proclaimed that “it’s time for women to know the facts.” Because how could we possibly “know the facts” about what’s happening in our own bodies without her and her Republican colleagues forcing them on us?

Senator Kathleen Vinehout (D) pointed out that not a single one of the constituents in her district asked for this bill or expressed support for it. She related the concerns of a couple of her constituents, one of whom pointed out that only 16 percent of rapes are reported, that one in six women in the U.S. will at some point in their life experience rape, and that that comes to more than 400,000 Wisconsin women.

Senator Lazich dismissed Sen. Vinehout’s “theatrics” (before proceeding with her own) by pointing out that the bill exempts rape and incest. Does it also exempt unreported rapes? Because those are the rapes Sen. Vinehout was referring to. In case you forgot, that’s 84 percent of rapes.

Here’s how it went down:
 

For those who don’t have the stomach to watch the video (and believe me, I don’t blame you one bit—watching it over and over again to get all the juicy quotes was truly nauseating), let me describe to you the “very cold, cold procedure and what happened, and the cold environment” in which democracy was dealt yet another death blow in Wisconsin.

Your voice and the voices of many of your legislative representatives were dismissed and discounted. After Senator Lazich’s animated testimony, Democratic senators tried to continue, but they were silenced. Senate President Mike Ellis came completely unhinged and shouted while slamming down his gavel so hard that it broke: “You’re out of order! Sit down! You’re not recognized! The question before the house is nondebatable. Call the roll!”

So that’s how democracy dies in Wisconsin. At least it was with some drama and the perfect symbolism of a broken gavel. And once this bill passes, we will have to live with it “day after day after day after day” for the rest of our lives. The women of Wisconsin will have to “live with this trauma” of having our voices silenced, of having our knowledge and judgment questioned, of having unnecessary medical procedures forced upon us by a legislature that refuses to hear our voices or even consider our concerns. “And it’s time for that to end.”

It’s time for those whom Senator Lazich and Senator Ellis purport to represent to know the facts about how their senators are carrying on in the state capitol in their name and what they’re doing when they reelect these legislative bullies over and over again. “If you have a loved one that’s thinking about” voting Republican, “for crying out loud, you want them to have full information. … You want them to know what’s going on” in that legislative body and “what they’re doing and that they’re not going to be able to change that for the rest of their life. They make that decision. It’s over. It’s over in a few minutes, and then later on they can live with the fact that” with that one decision in the voting booth, they supported the death of democracy in Wisconsin.

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Nondebatable!

  1. The problem with sharing this to “loved one’s that are thinking about voting republican” is that it probably won’t change their mind. Most would agree with the crap that’s going on. Sad to say.

  2. Thanks. That’s good to know. But will they back up all these words with action? Will large numbers of doctors commit civil disobedience in order to protect medical ethics? Honestly, I don’t see why pro-life doctors wouldn’t object to this legislative overreach as much as pro-choice doctors. Currently, state governments in power are trying to forcefully override medical judgment in order to prevent abortions. What if in the future, those governments try to override medical judgment in order to mandate abortions? You’d think the Right, paranoid as they are, would think of this, too; but no.

  3. Deeming any question or vote before any Federal or State House “Non-Debatable” is grounds for immediate removal of the Chairman. Our Constitutional Founders purposely engineered our Nation so that it could never be Totalitarian. Ellis must go….TODAY!

  4. Primum non nocere, or “First, do no harm”.

    Do you think putting rape victims through further emotional trauma and an unnecessary medical procedure is doing no harm??
    I hope doctors will stand up against this harmful bill.

    • They claim this law won’t apply to rape victims, completely ignoring the fact that approximately 84 percent of rapes go unreported. I really believe that they just don’t care. Lazich called Sen. Vinehout’s testimony, including her being a victim of rape herself at the age of 15, “theatrics.” That’s their response to rape victims. It’s unconscionable.

  5. I consider myself pro-life and I think this legislation and Ellis’s behavior are horrible. Is there no hope that a movement of doctors could arise to refuse to obey a law that they believe forces them to practice medicine unethically? Why isn’t this happening where these laws are being passed?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s